OneOff OneOff Black Toro

OneOffOneOff BlackToro (6" × 52 Toro)

92%4.6 / 5 stars
PrivadaCOMMUNITY5 Verified Ratings
93%93 / 100
CRITICS3 Reviews
Revived OneOff by Illusione; Black Toro (formerly Black & Tan naming). Nicaraguan puro made at Aganorsa; limited releases—line category on Illusione site; confirm Toro SKU with retailer alerts.
Length

6"

Gauge

52

Wrapper

Nicaraguan

Smoke time

~1h 51m

What to know

Critics consensus

After extended rest the profile centers on unsweetened cocoa and roasted peanut, with brownie-like richness on the nose and espresso anchoring the mid-palate. Earlier charred-meat edges have softened into a smoother, still-full arc. — Halfwheel (Mar 2026).

Read critic reviews

Community says

"Compared notes with a friend on the OneOff Black Toro — we both had clean draws and about the same timing through each third." — Diana

Read community reviews

After Aging Re-Score

Legacy · 93

Scores from major publications over time (not community ratings).

Critic reviews

The pros

Verified publication scores only. Want to contribute as a critic? Apply Here.

  • Halfwheel logo

    Halfwheel

    Published Mar 2026

    Critic

    After extended rest the profile centers on unsweetened cocoa and roasted peanut, with brownie-like richness on the nose and espresso anchoring the mid-palate. Earlier charred-meat edges have softened into a smoother, still-full arc.

    91 critic score

    Go to Full Review
  • Cigar Aficionado logo

    Cigar Aficionado

    Published Jan 2026

    Critic

    Sweet-salt tension: almond paste and white pepper over leather and toasted grain, with rustic depth rather than flash.

    94 critic score

    Go to Full Review
  • Cigar Aficionado logo

    Cigar Aficionado

    Published Dec 2025

    Critic

    Brilliant sweet-and-spicy array: marzipan, white pepper, leather, and hearty grains with rustic depth.

    94 critic score

    Go to Full Review

Community reviews

The smokers

Member ratings and notes from the community.

  • Diana

    Verified purchase
    5/5
    Strength 4Body 5Flavor 5Construction 5

    Compared notes with a friend on the OneOff Black Toro — we both had clean draws and about the same timing through each third.

    May 12, 2026

  • Ethan

    Verified purchase
    5/5
    Strength 5Body 5Flavor 5Construction 5

    Quiet Sunday with OneOff Black Toro. Retrohale had more spice than the palate, which I liked.

    Mar 25, 2026

  • Janet

    Verified purchase
    5/5
    Strength 5Body 5Flavor 5Construction 5

    Paired OneOff Black Toro with a dark lager; the malt and the cigar's cocoa notes lined up nicely.

    Feb 5, 2026

  • Big

    Verified purchase
    4/5
    Strength 3Body 5Flavor 3Construction 5

    OneOff Black Toro: good marriage of strength and sweetness for my taste. Would buy again.

    Dec 19, 2025

  • Carlos

    Verified purchase
    4/5
    Strength 4Body 4Flavor 3Construction 4

    The OneOff Black Toro impressed on construction. Flavor was a touch lighter than I expected from the scores but still enjoyable.

    Nov 1, 2025

Cigar info

Brand
OneOff
Line
OneOff Black Toro
Vitola
Toro